| Week 1 (10/1/2023) | Big Apple Nick vs Big Apple Dallas |
| Week 1 (10/1/2023) | Big Apple Dave vs Big Apple Eric |
| Week 2 (10/8/2023) | Big Apple Eric vs Big Apple Nick |
| Week 2 (10/8/2023) | Big Apple Dallas vs Big Apple Rex |
| Week 3 (10/15/2023) | Big Apple Dallas vs Big Apple Eric |
| Week 3 (10/15/2023) | Big Apple Dave vs Big Apple Rex |
| Week 4 (10/22/2023) | Big Apple Rex vs Big Apple Eric |
| Week 4 (10/22/2023) | Big Apple Dave vs Big Apple Nick |
| Week 5 (10/29/2023) | Big Apple Nick vs Big Apple Rex |
| Week 5 (10/29/2023) | Big Apple Dallas vs Big Apple Dave |
| Week 6 (11/5/2023) | Big Apple Eric vs Big Apple Dave |
| Week 6 (11/5/2023) | Big Apple Dallas vs Big Apple Nick |
| Week 7 (11/12/2023) | Big Apple Rex vs Big Apple Dallas |
| Week 7 (11/12/2023) | Big Apple Nick vs Big Apple Eric |
| Week 8 (11/19/2023) | Big Apple Rex vs Big Apple Dave |
| Week 8 (11/19/2023) | Big Apple Eric vs Big Apple Dallas |
| Week of 11/26/2023 | No Leagues - Happy thanksgiving |
| Week 9 (12/3/2023) | Big Apple Eric vs Big Apple Rex |
| Week 9 (12/3/2023) | Big Apple Nick vs Big Apple Dave |
| Week 10 (12/10/2023) | Big Apple Rex vs Big Apple Nick |
| Week 10 (12/10/2023) | Big Apple Dave vs Big Apple Dallas |
| Week 11 (12/17/2023) | Big Apple Nick vs Big Apple Dallas |
| Week 11 (12/17/2023) | Big Apple Dave vs Big Apple Eric |
| Week of 12/24/2023 | No Leagues - Christmas |
| Week of 12/31/2023 | No Leagues - New years |
| Week 12 (1/7/2024) | Big Apple Rex vs Big Apple Dallas |
| Week 12 (1/7/2024) | Big Apple Eric vs Big Apple Nick |
| Week 13 (1/14/2024) | Big Apple Dallas vs Big Apple Eric |
| Week 13 (1/14/2024) | Big Apple Dave vs Big Apple Rex |
| Week 14 (1/21/2024) | Big Apple Rex vs Big Apple Eric |
| Week 14 (1/21/2024) | Big Apple Dave vs Big Apple Nick |
| Week 15 (1/28/2024) | Big Apple Nick vs Big Apple Rex |
| Week 15 (1/28/2024) | Big Apple Dallas vs Big Apple Dave |