| Player | Team(s) | Consecutive Wins |
| Dave Bartlett | Kikkers Short Bus All Stars | 13 |
| Coby Young | Kikkers Short Bus All Stars | 5 |
| Dustin Gunia | Main Street Tavern Meehan, Main Street Tavern Muggers | 4 |
| Jon Allen | Main Street Tavern Meehan, Main Street Tavern Muggers, Main Street Tavern Thurman | 4 |
| Mike Rockwood | Kikkers Short Bus All Stars, Main Street Tavern Thurman | 4 |