| Player | Team(s) | Consecutive Wins |
| Dustin Smith | Main Street Tavern Nitro Break | 4 |
| Erran "El Captain of Amandas Boy's" Long | 13th St Brickhouse Polito, Main Street Tavern X-Men | 4 |
| Jacob Stevenson | Blue Legends Breaking Bad | 4 |
| Jamin Walters | Main Street Tavern Nitro Break | 4 |
| Dan Moscato | 13th St Brickhouse Polito | 3 |