| Player | Team(s) | Consecutive Wins |
| Travis Stokes | Main Street Tavern Greg, Main Street Tavern Tim | 6 |
| Tom Neighbors JR | Main Street Tavern Becky, Main Street Tavern Greg, Main Street Tavern Kellie | 5 |
| Troy Garrison | Main Street Tavern Dick, Main Street Tavern Greg | 3 |
| Chasity Griffis | Main Street Tavern Chas, Main Street Tavern Greg, Main Street Tavern Tim | 3 |
| Jimmy Bulanda | Main Street Tavern Jeff | 2 |